With most of the MBA exams like CATNMATSNAPTISS-NETIIFT entrance over now, Careers360.com brings you a series on toppers’ GD-PI-WAT experience.

 

In this interview, CAT topper Nitin Tibrewal who cracked FMS- Delhi GD-PI to secure admission to the coveted B-school, shares his experiences on the second stage of admission process with MBA aspirants.

To prepare for CAT 2014 click here

 

An NIT Durgapur graduate, Nitin is currently pursuing his MBA at FMS- Delhi. The fresher also received final admission offer from MDI Gurgaon.

 

The topper who appeared for the second stage of selection process at SPJIMR also, speaks on key highlights of GD-PI experience at other B-schools as well and shares GD-PI preparation tips. He elaborates on the factors which influenced his selection at FMS Delhi.  He also shares how the interview board hurled question based on the profile of another candidate and how he responded to the challenge before politely correcting them on their mistake.

 

Shortlist the B-Schools before they shortlist you. Predict your college with our CAT Pathfinder Tool

 

 For any doubt and query related to GD, PI and WAT/Essay Writing, call the GD PI WAT helpline number, 011- 40 360 360.

 

Group Discussion (GD) Experience

 

Careers360: How was your overall GD experience?

NitinTibrewal: It was an amazing experience. I gave a structure to the GD. The group coordination was good. We reached a consensus. I was delighted to be a part of the success of the GD.

 

 
 
 
 

“I believe an aspirant should start brushing up his General Knowledge as soon as possible. But, for the overall GD practice, January (once the results are out) is a good time to start. The preparation should start with your analysis of strengths and weaknesses, followed by planning on how to improve and/or tackle them. Finally, practicing as many GDs as possible on varied topics to gain confidence is very important.”

 
 
 
 

Careers360: How did your GD start?

NitinTibrewal: First, a moderator provided us with the topic and then left the discussion to start on our own after 5 minutes. Thereafter, post the discussion, he asked one of us to volunteer and summarize the discussion.

 

Careers360: How big was your group size what was your GD topic?

Nitin Tibrewal: There were 15members in our group. The topic was: ‘The increasing complexity of life today is creating more problems than it is solving’.

 

Careers360: What was your approach to the topic during GD?

NitinTibrewal: My approach was to look at all perspectives from where complexities would be analyzed: technological advancements, political independence, cultural freedom, social outlook, legal, economic issues and other issues. Thereafter, to analyze each issue at length, listing out the problems and solutions provided by each area and finally, to conclude about the topic and our views.

 

Careers360:  How did you defend your logic during the discussion?

NitinTibrewal: The group largely supported my points. But some of the members brought in the other side of the same coin and tried to weigh them up against my points to determine if the complexities are indeed creating or solving problems.

 

I defended my logic by quoting relevant authors on their perspectives and supporting them with relevant facts. But largely, my idea was to back it up with strong logic and my perspective on it.

 

Careers360: How many people from your group were finally selected or offered admission?

NitinTibrewal: Only One.

 

Careers360: How long did your GD last?

NitinTibrewal: My group discussion lasted for 15 minutes and 1 minute was given to us to summarize our discussions.

 

Careers360: Did your GD reach any conclusion?

NitinTibrewal: Yes, our GD reached a conclusion that indeed the complexities are creating more problems than they are solving, and the approach needs to be changed in order to use the complexities to solve the problems.

 

 
 
 
 

“Stay confident and calm. Be pleasant and happy. The first question mostly influences your chances of success.”

 
 
 
 

Careers360:  How did you prepare for your GD? When and how an aspirant should seriously start preparing for GD?

NitinTibrewal: I took help from TCC Management Systems, Kolkata, which guided my preparation by listing down areas of my strength and weaknesses, and guiding the overall improvement process. I believe an aspirant should start brushing up his General Knowledge as soon as possible. But, for the overall GD practice, January (once the results are out) is a good time to start. The preparation should start with your analysis of strengths and weaknesses, followed by planning on how to improve and/or tackle them. Finally, practicing as many GDs as possible on varied topics to gain confidence is very important.

 

Careers360: What were the key factors which you think influenced your selection at GD stage?

NitinTibrewal: My structure of thoughts and moderating act in the group, coupled with my inputs in the form of key points helped me score.

 

Careers360:  Did you appear for any other GD exercise at other top B-schools? Share a few experience.

NitinTibrewal: Other GDs were fine as well. I tried to gave a structure to the discussion and tried to moderate. But in some GDs, it became a fish market and it was difficult to moderate and put our inputs.

 

CAT-Pathfinder

 

Personal Interview (PI) Experience

 

Careers360: How many members were there in your interview board?

NitinTibrewal: There were three members in my interview board.

 

Careers360: How was the interview structured? What was the percentage of questions asked from your academic background, professional experience, interest, and generic issues?

NitinTibrewal: The interview started off with an extempore. Thereafter, questions on the extempore and family business. There was almost no question from the academic or professional background. Only 1 question on hobby was asked.

 

Careers360: What was the toughest area for you to answer?

NitinTibrewal: The toughest area was questions on my family business. They went deep into enquiring about the same. I tackled them quite calmly answering almost every question honestly.

 

Careers360:   What was the toughest moment during your PI?

NitinTibrewal: The toughest moment was when the interviewer confused me with another candidate and asked me questions on my background (actually his background, considering me to be him). I tackled them quite calmly. Finally I cleared the confusion.

 

Careers360:  What were the key factors which you think influenced your selection at PI stage?

NitinTibrewal: My calmness, confidence and honesty.

 

Careers360:  What is your advice to aspirants for Personal Interview?

NitinTibrewal:  Stay confident and calm. Be pleasant and happy. The first question mostly influences your chances of success.

 

Careers360:     Did you appear for any other PI exercise at other top B-schools? Please share a few experiences (where you went wrong).

NitinTibrewal: I went through the Group Interview at SP Jain, where I was grilled on my hobbies, particularly reading. What went wrong was myself getting a little stressed. Then at MDI, I was again grilled on my hobbies. This time I answered calmly and got selected as well.

 

Careers360: How did you prepare for your PI? When and how an aspirant should seriously start preparing for PI?

NitinTibrewal: The preparation should start with your analysis of strengths and weaknesses, followed by planning on how to improve and/or tackle them. Finally, appearing at as many mock interviews as possible is important to gain confidence and exposure to various situations.

 

Careers360: Any interesting moment from your PI which you would like to share with MBA aspirants?

NitinTibrewal: The panel was also a football enthusiast like me. The members discussed quite a lot with me and spent around 20 minutes arguing over football. In the end, we both laughed off at the playing style of different clubs.

 

Also read:

 

GD-PI-WAT: How Akshay Jayaprakasan secured admission to IIM Kozhikode?

GD-PI-WAT: How I converted my call from IIM?

Stay tuned to bschool.careers360.com for more topper interview on GD-PI-WAT for MBA admissions.

Applications Open Now

SRMHCAT 2020 | Last Date to Apply: 26 May'20
SRMHCAT 2020 | Last Date to A...
Apply
Amity Global Business School Noida
Amity Global Business School ...
Apply
ITM Business School
ITM Business School
Apply
IMS UC Campus
IMS UC Campus
Apply
NMIMS MBA (Family Business) Admissions Deadline 25 May
NMIMS MBA (Family Business) A...
Apply
Vishwakarma University MBA Admissions 2020
Vishwakarma University MBA Ad...
Apply
Integral University Admissions 2020
Integral University Admission...
Apply
View All Application Forms

Popular Degrees

3962 Colleges
546 Colleges
116 Colleges
79 Colleges
490 Colleges

Popular Branches

Colleges available: 6937
Colleges available: 687
Colleges available: 319
Colleges available: 292
Colleges available: 262
View All Branches

Latest Articles

Questions related to CAT

Showing 8459 out of 8459 Questions
3 Views

Where can one gain knowledge from experiences of industry personalities and their careers?

Apoorva Student Expert 27th May, 2020

Hello dear student,

there are so many places where you can gain knowledge from the experiences of the personalities from the industry directly. You can attend workshops organised by them and gain understanding of their experiences. Then you can attend their seminars , webinars etc . That ways will be easier and helpful. While you can also just Google it and read all about them.

Thank you

18 Views

my overall marks in board is 60%. individually I passed all sub but individually not 50 mark in each pcb but I from obc cat. and gujarat board phy the+pra 39+41 ,bio the +prac 68+36 and che the+prac 41+41 am I eligible for neet 2020 and its counseling?

Priyaanka Sarkar Student Expert 25th May, 2020
You needn't score 50% or 40% individually in Physics, Chemistry and Biology. If you belong to OBC, you shpuld score 40% on average in Physics, Chemistry and Biology to be eligible for NEET. With your marks, you will be eligible for NEET 2020. So nothing to be worried about.
8 Views

my pcb theory +practical 60% I passed 2020 guj board 2020.obc cat. am I eligible for neet 2020

Priyaanka Sarkar Student Expert 24th May, 2020
For a Candidate belonging to OBC, he/she should have completed his/her 12th, passed in all subjects including theory and secure a minimum aggregate of 40% in Physics, Chemistry and Biology. This 40% should include Theory and Practicals. With 60%, you have secured marks more than required for your aggregate. And so you are eligible for NEET 2020.
58 Views

Does Jbims accept CAT score of Mumbai base students?

Shubham Dhane 23rd May, 2020

Hello,

To get admission in Jamnalal Bajaj Institute of Management Studies, Mumbai you need to give MAH MBA CET and qualify the exam. Final admission of the candidates will be based on the performance in written test and group discussion. Please click the below link to know more.

https://www.careers360.com/colleges/jamnalal-bajaj-institute-of-management-studies-mumbai

23 Views

im done my gradution with 45.91%an now i want to do mba in retail Management so can you guide me for that and also show me eligibility CAT and CET

Priyaanka Sarkar Student Expert 24th May, 2020

Vicky, CAT is the entrance examination for admission to all the 20 IIMs and over 1000 participating Institutions for their Management programmes. To be eligible for CAT, you should have completed your Graduation in any discipline with a minimum aggregate of 50%. It is 50% for General Category and 45% for Reserved Categories. Now if you belong to General Category, unfortunately you do not qualify for CAT. Regarding CET, ever State has its own CET and so please do help us with the State you belong to.

Top
The question have been saved in answer later, you can access it from your profile anytime. Access now

Download the Careers360 App on your Android phone

Regular exam updates, QnA, Predictors, College Applications & E-books now on your Mobile

Careers360 App
150M+ Students
24,000+ Colleges
500+ Exams
1500+ E-books