IIMs! Don’t use testing partner as shield to evade CAT answer sheet release

IIMs! Don’t use testing partner as shield to evade CAT answer sheet release

Indian Institutes of Management (IIMs) have been evading CAT answer key requests and other RTI requests related to CAT evaluation process in the name of RTI exemption clauses. But the escape route that IIMs have taken so far does not stand legal scrutiny as the Supreme Court restricts public exam authorities taking shield of testing partners to evade answer sheet release. In its order relating to answer key release, SC order says that “no exemption under section 8 is available in respect of evaluated answer books” and hence “the examining bodies will have to permit inspection sought by the examinees.”

 

CAT Pathfinder
Know your call chances for top B-schools through CAT

Careers360 has earlier reported how IIMs have been violating Supreme Court order that binds public exam authorities to release answer sheet or response sheet if requested by examinees.

 

We further dig into the Supreme Court order to bring clarity on why the secrecy that IIMs maintain in the name of RTI exemption is not legally valid.

 

What IIMs say is illegal

On requests for Common Admission Tests (CAT)  answer keys from CAT examinees, IIMs have maintained that answer key release is not required as they already follow standard testing and evaluation practices.

 

Further, they cite commercial interest of their testing partners as the reason behind not making the mechanical evaluation process public.

 

Another argument that they present is that the announcement of answer keys/response sheet and raw scores will create confusion among test takers.

 

None of the above logics stand in the face of the SC order in this regard.

 

Interest of third party (testing partner) can not hinder ‘right to information’

The Supreme Court order says that examining body is the ‘principal’ and the examiner is the agent entrusted with the work, that is, evaluation of answer-books. The order further says that once the paper is evaluated, it again becomes the record held by exam authorities and not the examiner. Therefore, third party interest can’t be cited as a reason under RTI Act for not sharing answer sheets by public exam authorities.

 

“Once the examiner has evaluated the answer books, he ceases to have any interest in the evaluation done by him. He does not have any copyright or proprietary right, or confidentiality right in regard to the evaluation. Therefore it cannot be said that the examining body holds the evaluated answer books in a fiduciary relationship, qua the examiner,” the SC order reads.

 

In complete violation of the SC order, an IIM evaded a specific reply to a CAT taker who requested information on his CAT performance, through an RTI application. Taking shield of its testing agency, the concerned IIM denied the information saying the details if divulged “will affect their (testing agency) commercial interest and thus barred from disclosure.”

 

Careers360 brings SC order excerpts which define fiduciary relationship (relationship of trust):

 

“Fiduciary relationship:  On a careful examination we find that this contention has no merit. The examining body entrusts the answer-books to an examiner for evaluation and pays the examiner for his expert service. The work of evaluation and marking the answer-book is an assignment given by the examining body to the examiner which he discharges for a consideration. Sometimes, an examiner may assess answer-books, in the course of his employment, as a part of his duties without any specific or special remuneration. In other words, the examining body is the ‘principal’ and the examiner is the agent entrusted with the work, that is, evaluation of answer-books. Therefore, the examining body is not in the position of a fiduciary with reference to the examiner. On the other hand, when an answer-book is entrusted to the examiner for the purpose of evaluation, for the period the answer-book is in his custody and to the extent of the discharge of his functions relating to evaluation, the examiner is in the position of a fiduciary with reference to the examining body and he is barred from disclosing the contents of the answer-book or the result of evaluation of the answer-book to anyone other than the examining body. Once the examiner has evaluated the answer books, he ceases to have any interest in the evaluation done by him. He does not have any copyright or proprietary right, or confidentiality right in regard to the evaluation. Therefore it cannot be said that the examining body holds the evaluated answer books in a fiduciary relationship, qua the examiner.”

 

“We, therefore, hold that an examining body does not hold the evaluated answer-books in a fiduciary relationship. Not being information available to an examining body in its fiduciary relationship, the exemption under section 8(1)(e) is not available to the examining bodies with reference to evaluated answer-books. As no other exemption under section 8 is available in respect of evaluated answer books, the examining bodies will have to permit inspection sought by the examinees.”

 

Thus, the Supreme Court in its crucial order maintained that the response sheet, which is evaluated by exam authorities, is a record of information which essentially falls under the purview of RTI. The IIMs, however, have not only been refusing to share the evaluated response sheet but also denying access to answer keys of its question papers, which according to the Supreme Court is a piece of information that can be shared with candidates.

 

Will CAT take a step forward for transparency?

Ever since CAT turned computer-based, the question papers are no more accessible to the candidates or others, after the test. This often raises questions regarding the credibility of evaluation and scoring process as the test takers cannot revisit questions and estimate their score.

 

Till 2013, the test was conducted in a window of 20 days, 2 slots each day. This meant, there were 40 question papers, which might not have been feasible for the authorities to upload.  However, in 2014 the test was conducted in 2 days with 4 slots and the window was further reduced to a single day with 2 slots in 2015. With a shorter window, the IIMs could have conveniently shared or uploaded the question papers which would have only helped the test takers. It would have also helped the future MBA aspirants to know the types of questions to expect, important topics, difficulty level etc.  Despite having a shorter window and lesser number of slots, IIMs are still not open about making the question papers public.

 

Making the question papers available is a standard practice which is followed by many high profile competitive exams like JEE, NEET, UPSC etc. Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE), which conducts the Joint Entrance Exam (JEE) for the engineering admission to IITs, NITs, IIITs and GFTIs makes question papers available not only for offline paper but also for the test conducted in computer-based mode. Further, answer keys for these exams are also released after the exam. This makes the test process completely transparent and helps strengthen its credibility.

 

Test conducting authorities like CBSE (Joint Entrance Exam) and XLRI Jamshedpur (XAT) make individual answer sheet of the candidates accessible to them on their individual login ID, making the process further transparent after releasing question paper and answer keys. For CAT, IIMs deny any such access to candidates to go back and see what they have marked in their answer sheet.

 

Similarly, CAT takers also look for question papers and answer keys for more transparency in the system. Also, the answer keys help test takers to estimate their score and help them plan admission at a suitable B-School.

 

Being a public examination body and elite league of management institutions, IIMs are expected to lead ways for transparency.

 

If IIMs release all three above documents, question paper, answer key and answer sheet, then the major issues related to lack of transparency can be addressed. The need to release the important documents are realised even more when controversies like securing 55 percentile in CAT despite ‘no’ attempts ensue.

 

Will IIMs come straight on this? Will they take a step forward towards greater transparency in their testing and evaluation system?

 

Also Read:

 

SC order strict on release of answer sheet; IIMs remain non-committal on CAT

 

IIMs must release CAT Question Paper and Keys for transparency, says CAT expert Arks Srinivas

 

CAT Troubles: Will IIMs address these problem areas bothering CAT takers every year?

First Published On : 14 Oct 2016 06:57 PM IST

Related Articles

Suggested Reading: IIM|CAT

QNA - EXAM QUESTIONS AND ANSWERS

CAT

Join this QNA topic to get updates about latest happenings about the exam!

  • 13612 Joined
  • 2843 Questions
User Pic

Ashutosh Yadav 3 hours ago

Ashutosh Yadavs picture
Ashutosh YadavLast Seen: 1 hour 16 min agoJoined on: 24-Aug-2017Education Interest: MBAEducation Level: Graduate & Above

Actually 10clss me 40% ha Nd 12th 51% , Nd BBA 60% ha, if I m take good %lie in cat so any IIM Nd FMS collage call me or not

I m SC category SE belong karta hu ,so any change to take ha good colg

Answer (1)

K

KRITI GOEL 2 hours ago

KRITI GOELs picture
KRITI GOELLast Seen: 2 hours 2 min agoJoined on: 02-Jun-2018Education Interest: ManagementEducation Level: Graduate & Above

Hello,

There are chances that you can get call for iim or fms because you are in reserved category.

But you need to work hard and should have good percentile to be eligible.

Thank you!

Good luck!!

B

bb ki vines 17 hours ago

bb ki viness picture
Bb Ki VinesLast Seen: 3 hours 25 min agoJoined on: 15-Jul-2018Education Interest: ManagementEducation Level: In Graduation

Please send me links of CAT Xam study material I am a very poor student please help me.

Answers (2)

B

bb ki vines 16 hours ago

bb ki viness picture
Bb Ki VinesLast Seen: 3 hours 25 min agoJoined on: 15-Jul-2018Education Interest: ManagementEducation Level: In Graduation
Waise Career360 app m bhi Janta hu (:-(:-(:-

View All Answers

S

Salik Siddiqui 18 hours ago

Salik Siddiquis picture
Salik SiddiquiLast Seen: 7 hours 20 min agoJoined on: 21-Jul-2018Education Interest: ManagementEducation Level: Class 10 or below

Is CAT is important to take admission in BBA?

Answers (3)

User Pic

ANAND D 16 hours ago

ANAND Ds picture
ANAND DLast Seen: 14 hours 4 min agoJoined on: 17-May-2018Education Interest: ManagementEducation Level: Graduate & Above

hai.

cat is basically used for pg level admission process especially for mba. so for bba cat is not required.

if you have any more queries feel free to contact.

thank you

View All Answers

T

TAPISH GUPTA 18 hours ago

TAPISH GUPTAs picture
TAPISH GUPTALast Seen: 17 hours 36 min agoJoined on: 21-Jul-2018Education Interest: Degree ProgrammesEducation Level: Class 12

IF I AM NOW 12 PASSED. AND I WANT TO GONE INTO IIM PLEASE SUGGEST ME

Answers (2)

K

KRITI GOEL 18 hours ago

KRITI GOELs picture
KRITI GOELLast Seen: 2 hours 2 min agoJoined on: 02-Jun-2018Education Interest: ManagementEducation Level: Graduate & Above

Hello,

You can enroll in institutes who provide CAT coaching and can pursue self study which is most important to crack CAT exam. You need to work hard to be in top colleges.

Thank you!

Good luck!

View All Answers

B

bb ki vines 19 hours ago

bb ki viness picture
Bb Ki VinesLast Seen: 3 hours 25 min agoJoined on: 15-Jul-2018Education Interest: ManagementEducation Level: In Graduation

Please suggest me a source of free notes of CAT Xam It will be very helpful for a needy student like me

Answers (2)

User Pic

ANAND D 15 hours ago

ANAND Ds picture
ANAND DLast Seen: 14 hours 4 min agoJoined on: 17-May-2018Education Interest: ManagementEducation Level: Graduate & Above
hai.you need to use the internet facility in depth for it. you will get a plenty of study materials for this examination. one sample link is given below:http://mbacatmaterial.blogspot.com/p/other-mate...Read More

View All Answers