5 B-Schools That Were Unfairly Ranked in NIRF 2024: Parameters, Placement, Salary

5 B-Schools That Were Unfairly Ranked in NIRF 2024: Parameters, Placement, Salary

Edited By Team Careers360 | Updated on Aug 27, 2024 05:56 PM IST | #IMI Delhi

The NIRF rankings have long been a benchmark for MBA aspirants in India, guiding them toward choosing the right B-school. However, the 2024 rankings have sparked significant debate due to surprising placements that raise questions about the methodology. Many well-regarded institutions have been overshadowed by lesser-known private colleges, despite stronger credentials in parameters like placements, salary packages, academic excellence, and industry connections. Here, we explore five B-schools that, based on their performance and reputation, deserve higher recognition in the NIRF 2024 rankings but seem to have been unfairly placed.

5 B-Schools That Were Unfairly Ranked in NIRF 2024: Parameters, Placement, Salary
5 B-Schools That Were Unfairly Ranked in NIRF 2024: Parameters, Placement, Salary

5 B-Schools That Were Unfairly Ranked in NIRF 2024

The NIRF ranking, introduced by the Government of India, is a significant step toward systematically evaluating Indian institutions based on various parameters.

NIRF MBA Ranking 2024: Parameters

Parameters

Ranking Weight

Teaching, Learning & Resources (TLR)

30%

Research and Professional Practice (RP)

30%

Graduation Outcomes (GO)

20%

Outreach and Inclusivity (OI)

10%

Perception (PR)

10%

NIRF Management Ranking 2024: Year-Wise Rank Difference

Unfairly Ranked Colleges in NIRF 2024

NIRF 2024

Rank Difference

NIRF 2023

IMI Delhi

40

-6

34

TAPMI, Manipal

58

-16

42

KREA University

99

-25

74

K J Somaiya, Mumbai

63

-18

45

BIMTECH, Greater Noida

64

-16

48

Placement details of MBA colleges that were unfairly ranked in the NIRF 2024

Unfairly Ranked MBA Colleges in NIRF 2024

Placement Percentage

Median Salary

IMI Delhi

100%

16,33,000

TAPMI, Manipal

100%

13,50,000

KREA University

100%

13,10,000

K J Somaiya, Mumbai

99%

11,00,000

BIMTECH, Greater Noida

100%

11,00,000

International Management Institute, Delhi

IMI New Delhi was established in 1981 and is India's first corporate sponsored business school. IMI Delhi offers admission in PGDM, PGDM (HRM), PGDM (B&FS), PGDM Online, 18th Month PGDM, and Fellow Program in Management (FPM).

NIRF 2024 Parameters

TLR (100)

RPC (100)

GO (100)

OI (100)

Perception (100)

72.25

26.29

87.23

69.58

9.12

T. A. Pai Management Institute (TAPMI)

TAPMI was established as Manipal Institute of Management in 1980. It is the fifth institute in India to have dual accreditations (AMBA & AACSB). In 1981, it was renamed to T.A. Pai Management Institute in honour of our founder. TAPMI offers full-time programmes in MBA, MBA (BKFS), MBA (HRM), MBA (Marketing), MBA (IB).

NIRF 2024 Parameters

TLR (100)

RPC (100)

GO (100)

OI (100)

Perception (100)

60.10

25.90

81.91

70.48

15.51

KREA University

KREA was established in 1970 as a not-for-profit society, the Institute for Financial Management and Research (IFMR). KREA Univesity offers full-time management programmes MBA, Integrated MBA, and Executive MBA.

NIRF 2024 Parameters

TLR (100)

RPC (100)

GO (100)

OI (100)

Perception (100)

69.73

2.22

64.61

73.15

9.98

K. J. Somaiya Institute of Management, Mumbai

Somaiya Vidyavihar was established by Padmabhushan Late Shri K J Somaiya in 1959. The institute offers admission in MBA, MBA in Working Executives, MBA in Healthcare Management, MBA in Sports Management, and Executive MBA.

NIRF 2024 Parameters

TLR (100)

RPC (100)

GO (100)

OI (100)

Perception (100)

68.84

23.02

72.59

66.72

9.12

Birla Institute of Management Technology, Greater Noida

BIMTECH was established in 1988 under the Birla Academy of Arts and Culture, and supported by the Birla Group of Companies. The institute offers full-time programmes in PGDM, PGDM (IB), PGDM (IBM), PGDM (RM), and PGDM Online.

NIRF 2024 Parameters

TLR (100)

RPC (100)

GO (100)

OI (100)

Perception (100)

67.23

18.69

80.54

65.89

9.55

Conclusion

NIRF's rankings do not do justice to MBA rankings and should not become a consideration factor while selecting or targeting B-schools. The factors included do not specify the points an aspirant would need to evaluate their results.

There are differences not only in MBA colleges but also in undergraduate colleges. To make the right decision, one should check factors like placements, alumni networks, company visits and roles offered, ROI, brand value, and batch size.

Articles

Explore Top Universities Across Globe

University of Essex, Colchester
 Wivenhoe Park Colchester CO4 3SQ
Oxford Brookes University, Oxford
 Headington Campus Oxford OX3 0BP UK
Northumbria University, Newcastle City Campus
 Sutherland Building, Northumberland Road, Newcastle-upon-Tyne, NE1 8ST
Cardiff Metropolitan University, Cardiff
 Llandaff Campus, Western Avenue, Cardiff, CF5 2YB
University of Reading, Reading
 Whiteknights PO Box 217 Reading Berkshire RG6 6AH
Bristol Baptist College, Bristol
 The Promenade, Clifton Down, Bristol BS8 3NJ

Questions related to IMI Delhi

Have a question related to IMI Delhi ?

Hello,

IMT Nagpur is generally better than IMI Kolkata in terms of brand value, alumni network, and corporate connections. IMT Nagpur has a higher average placement package (~9 LPA vs ~7 LPA at IMI Kolkata) and better faculty. however, IMI Kolkata is good for finance- related roles, so choose based on your specialization preference.

Hello Varun,

Based on your CAT raw score and profile, here's a breakdown of your potential calls and your chances for different institutes:

1. GIM Goa, GLIM Chennai, IMT Ghaziabad, IMI Delhi:

  • GIM Goa : With a score of 55, GIM typically looks for candidates with a higher percentile. However, you may still get a call if your overall profile, including your academic background (93.8% in Class 12, work experience), is strong.

  • GLIM Chennai : GLIM has a competitive cutoff, but with a solid academic record and work experience, there may be a chance, especially if you belong to a diverse background.

  • IMT Ghaziabad : Your chances with a score of 55 are slim, as IMT usually looks for a higher percentile. However, if you have an impressive profile and high academic scores, there may still be a slim possibility.

  • IMI Delhi : Similar to IMT, IMI Delhi has high cutoffs and competitive selection criteria. However, work experience and other factors like diversity can sometimes offset a lower CAT score.

    2. IIM SAP (Special Admission Program) :

  • The IIM SAP is typically for candidates with significant work experience or other unique factors. Your 14 months of work experience could be beneficial, but your CAT score of 55 is on the lower side, making it unlikely to receive an IIM SAP call. However, if you have other outstanding features in your profile (e.g., exceptional academic performance, leadership qualities, etc.), you might still stand a chance.

    3. Other Possible Calls :

  • UPES Dehradun : Known for considering work experience and unique profiles, UPES could be a potential option for you.

  • Bimtech Noida : You could expect a call here, considering your work experience and overall profile.

  • XIMB Bhubaneswar : This institute also considers profiles with good work experience, and you may stand a chance despite your score.

Overall, you can expect a call from institutes that weigh work experience and academic performance heavily, but you should also be prepared for lower-tier institutes in terms of CAT score cutoffs. Ensure you target institutes that match your profile for better chances.


I hope this answer helps you. If you have more queries then feel free to share your questions with us we will be happy to assist you.

Thank you and wishing you all the best for your bright future.


Hii,

If banking, finance, and insurance are of interest to you, pick GIM Goa (BFSI); it has a strong brand and excellent industry connections.
If you enjoy managing factories, supply chains, or logistics, SIOM Nashik (Operations) is the best option. It's a specialized field with excellent operations.
Overall, IMI Bhubaneswar (PGDM) is respectable, but not as good as SIOM or GIM.

GIM Goa (BFSI) is the best choice overall because of its superior brand, placements, and potential for expansion.
SIOM Nashik is the best for operations only.

Hello,

Generally, many institutes have a residential requirement, especially for full-time programs, to foster a conducive learning environment and promote holistic development among students. However, since your home is just 15 minutes from the campus, you may want to inquire directly. Mostly they'll agree with you as it is not worth for your to stay in campus. So connect with them they'll surely agree on this.

Hope this helps you,

Thank you

https://www.careers360.com/colleges/international-management-institute-kolkata



Dear aspirant,

I would be judging these two institutes on the basis of placements.

So, IMT nagpur has a very strong placement cell. All the training and placement related stuff is handled by the placement team. The students are trained through various training programmes to enhance their communication skills.

Students are placed across various sectors such as BFSI ,IT and ITES , service , hospitality, e-commerce ,consulting ,power , manufacturing, FMCG and retail and many more.

Whereas imi new dehli does not have strong grip in its placements.

To get complete information you can check out the link given below-

https://www.careers360.com/colleges/institute-of-management-technology-nagpur

View All
Marketing Director

A career as Marketing Director is also known as a marketing expert who is responsible for the overall marketing aspect of the company. He or she oversees plans and develops the company's budget. The marketing Director collaborates with the business team to plan and develop the marketing and branding strategies for the company's products or services. 

4 Jobs Available
Business Development Executive

A Business Development Executive identifies and pursues new business opportunities to drive company growth. They generate leads, build client relationships, develop sales strategies, and analyse market trends. Collaborating with internal teams, they aim to meet sales targets. With experience, they can advance to managerial roles, playing a key role in expanding the company’s market presence and revenue.

3 Jobs Available
Content Marketing Specialist

Content Marketing Specialists are also known as Content Specialists. They are responsible for crafting content, editing and developing it to meet the requirements of digital marketing campaigns. To ensure that the material created is consistent with the overall aims of a digital marketing campaign, content marketing specialists work closely with SEO and digital marketing professionals.

3 Jobs Available
Sales Manager

A Sales Manager leads a sales team to meet targets, formulates strategies, analyses performance, and monitors market trends. They typically hold a degree in management or related fields, with an MBA offering added value. The role often demands over 40 hours a week. Strong leadership, planning, and analytical skills are essential for success in this career.

2 Jobs Available
Marketing Manager

A marketing manager is a person who oversees a company or product marketing. He or she can be in charge of multiple programmes or goods or can be in charge of one product. He or she is enthusiastic, organised, and very diligent in meeting financial constraints. He or she works with other team members to produce advertising campaigns and decides if a new product or service is marketable. 

A Marketing manager plans and executes marketing initiatives to create demand for goods and services and increase consumer awareness of them. A marketing manager prevents unauthorised statements and informs the public that the business is doing everything to investigate and fix the line of products. Students can pursue an MBA in Marketing Management courses to become marketing managers.

2 Jobs Available
SEO Analyst

An SEO Analyst is a web professional who is proficient in the implementation of SEO strategies to target more keywords to improve the reach of the content on search engines. He or she provides support to acquire the goals and success of the client’s campaigns. 

2 Jobs Available
Digital Marketing Executive

Digital marketing is growing, diverse, and is covering a wide variety of career paths. Each job function aids in the development of effective digital marketing strategies and techniques. The aims and objectives of the individuals who opt for a career as a digital marketing executive are similar to those of a marketing professional: to build brand awareness, promote company services or products, and increase conversions. Individuals who opt for a career as Digital Marketing Executives, unlike traditional marketing companies, communicate effectively through suitable technology platforms.

2 Jobs Available
Business Analyst

Individuals who opt for a career as a business analyst look at how a company operates. He or she conducts research and analyses data to improve his or her knowledge about the company. This is required so that an individual can suggest the company strategies for improving their operations and processes.

In a business analyst  job role a lot of analysis is done, things are learned from past mistakes and the successful strategies are enhanced further. A business analyst goes through real-world data in order to provide the most feasible solutions to an organisation. Students can pursue Business Analytics to become Business Analysts. 

2 Jobs Available
Back to top